Without the Least Tremor: The Sacrifice of Socrates in Plato's Phaedo (SUNY series in Contemporary Continental Philosophy)

By M. Ross Romero

In Without the Least Tremor, M. Ross Romero considers the dying of Socrates as a sacrificial act instead of an execution, and analyzes the results of such an realizing for the which means of the "Phaedo." Plato s recounting of Socrates s demise matches the various conventions of historical Greek sacrificial ritual.

Among those are the bathtub, the procession, Socrates s visual appeal as a bull, the libation, the providing of a chicken to Asclepius, the therapy of Socrates s physique and corpse, and Phaedo s memorialization of Socrates. but in a robust second, Socrates s loss of life deviates from a sacrifice as he beverages the "pharmakon" with no the least tremor. constructing the topics of affliction and knowledge as they connect with this scene, Romero demonstrates how the embodied Socrates is surroundings forth an "eikon" of the demise of the thinker.

Drawing on comparisons with tragedy and comedy, he argues that Socrates s dying is extra fittingly defined as self-sacrifice than only an execution or suicide. After contemplating the consequences of those topics for the soul s immortality and its dating to the physique, the e-book concludes with an exploration of where of sacrifice inside moral life."

Show description

Quick preview of Without the Least Tremor: The Sacrifice of Socrates in Plato's Phaedo (SUNY series in Contemporary Continental Philosophy) PDF

Best Philosophy books

Philosophical Temperaments: From Plato to Foucault (Insurrections: Critical Studies in Religion, Politics, and Culture)

Peter Sloterdijk turns his prepared eye to the historical past of western proposal, undertaking colourful readings of the lives and concepts of the world's so much influential intellectuals. that includes nineteen vignettes wealthy in own characterizations and theoretical research, Sloterdijk's companionable quantity casts the improvement of philosophical pondering no longer as a buildup of compelling books and arguments yet as a lifelong, intimate fight with highbrow and non secular activities, jam-packed with as many pitfalls and derailments as transcendent breakthroughs.

Cut of the Real: Subjectivity in Poststructuralist Philosophy (Insurrections: Critical Studies in Religion, Politics, and Culture)

Following François Laruelle's nonstandard philosophy and the paintings of Judith Butler, Drucilla Cornell, Luce Irigaray, and Rosi Braidotti, Katerina Kolozova reclaims the relevance of different types commonly rendered "unthinkable" by way of postmodern feminist philosophies, equivalent to "the real," "the one," "the limit," and "finality," therefore seriously repositioning poststructuralist feminist philosophy and gender/queer reviews.

History of Shit (Documents Book)

Written in Paris after the heady days of pupil riot in may well 1968 and earlier than the devastation of the AIDS epidemic, background of Shit is emblematic of a wild and adventurous pressure of Seventies' theoretical writing that tried to marry concept, politics, sexuality, excitement, experimentation, and humor. noticeably redefining dialectical proposal and post-Marxist politics, it takes an important--and irreverent--position along the works of such postmodern thinkers as Foucault, Deleuze, Guattari, and Lyotard.

The Puppet and the Dwarf: The Perverse Core of Christianity (Short Circuits)

Slavoj Žižek has been known as "an educational rock megastar" and "the wild guy of theory"; his writing mixes surprising erudition and references to popular culture for you to dissect present highbrow pieties. In The Puppet and the Dwarf he deals an in depth interpreting of brand new spiritual constellation from the perspective of Lacanian psychoanalysis.

Extra resources for Without the Least Tremor: The Sacrifice of Socrates in Plato's Phaedo (SUNY series in Contemporary Continental Philosophy)

Show sample text content

And the outdated king burned those over dried cut up wooden and over the fireplace poured out glistening wine whereas younger males at his facet held five-pronged forks. as soon as they’d burned the bones and tasted the organs, they sliced the remainder into items, spitted them on skewers and elevating issues to the hearth, broiled the entire meats. (3. 510–520) This description, seriously prompted by way of culture, indicates how the percentage of the beef for the gods was once delineated from the proportion for people. Vernant writes, “Man’s percentage of the sacrificed animal is the useless, corruptible meat; the gods’ proportion is the smoke from the charred bones, the scent of perfumes, and incorruptible spices” (135). The ritual, accordingly, was once a big strategy to converse with the gods. As Gilhus issues out, “Rituals functionality specially to set up and make sure the truth of the gods. Killing animals in honour of them and supplying them a part of the beef from the sacrifice was once a method during which their truth used to be confirmed” (1). the upkeep of the gods throughout the smoky essence of elements of burned sufferers used to be regarded as utilising nectar and ambrosia to the gods, maintaining them within the Age of Zeus. As we will see, the sacrificial ritual used to be strongly motivated by way of a view of the connection of the gods to human time. As I famous at first of this description, one other aspect is the necessity to receive the “assent” of the sacrificial animal. At factor is whether the sacrificial sufferer was once required, via the restrictions of the ritual, to point its willingness to be sacrificed and the measure to which such consent may be fabricated or fictionalized. within the historical past of this is often the phenomenon of bloodguilt, the guilt got from laying off the blood of a sacrificial sufferer. As tragedies similar to Aeschylus’s Orestia attest, bloodguilt was once a major difficulty for the Greeks in Athens, and Detienne explains that during sacrificial ritual itself there has been nice worry A DESCRIPTION OF GREEK SACRIFICIAL RITUAL forty seven of incurring it (9). Burkert is one interpreter whose assumption approximately bloodguilt impacts his figuring out of sacrifice. Burkert follows Meuli, who argued that the Greeks skilled “angst” at having to kill a residing creature. This was once traceable to attitudes approximately searching. traditionally, this ritual of the sacrificial meal should be traced to the placement of guy earlier than the invention of agriculture: searching, particularly tremendous online game looking for farm animals and horses, was once the leading job of the male, and the valuable resource of nutrients for the relatives. Killing to consume was once an unalterable commandment, and but the bloody act should always were attended with a double possibility and a double worry: that the weapon should be grew to become opposed to a fellow hunter, and that the demise of the prey may perhaps sign an finish with out destiny, whereas guy should always consume and so should always hunt. (58) Burkert translates different parts of the sacrificial ritual at the foundation of this assumption that sacrifice is traceable to looking. for example, because the animal is introduced ahead to the altar, Burkert contends that water used to be poured over its head with a view to make it jerk or nod its head, which used to be interpreted by means of these current on the sacrifice because the sufferer giving its assent.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.68 of 5 – based on 41 votes